QueerClick

But the members only photo was a fake, supposedly.

I wonder if these are as well. You'd think a faked dick would be huge -- otherwise, what's the point, right?

Quite obviously a fake.
Someone's tried to be clever - and not done a very good job of it.
Shame - would have made a great early Xmas present.

These pictures are fakes! I saw a special about the making of this video and he is wearing black underwear beneath the censored patch.

I don't think it's real

Theylook pretty fake to me, but they help me imagine better anyway!

Ahhh, that is so fake, or is that the joke of it?

Well whether its fake or not, I think its all part of a fantasy I want with RW - LOL!, and yeah, so what if its meant to be a joke, it certainly brought a smile to my face! hehe :)

I guess there will always be detracters as to whether its real or not - I think thats irrelevant cos for sure Robbie Williams is the type of star who would be up for a laugh and actually doing it. I bet his management team get horrified at the idea of what he'll do next? haha!

also, Robbie's bush is huge -- we've all seen it. :) Another tipoff. :)

I suppose he could have had it trimmed especially for the video? LOL!!!

Totally fake. His dick doesn't look real in half of them anyway... like seriously, it looks like it was done in Paint.

HAHA! You guys are so funny there at QC! Yup that sure gave me a great laff seeing this, nice too see not too many actually took the whole thing tooooooo seriously, well I guess some have, but not too many, most people get the joke - LOL!!!

Hee! funny! but i bet his cock is nicer in real life?

Nuffin wrong wif a bit of creativity n paintshop to put a smile on all our faces!

Hi guys, wow there's quite a debate there. We're not sure the grabs are totally fake. ;)

The video that's been aired is the final version with Robbie's private parts blurred out. He was donning a pair of black briefs (with a tiger on it!) but he removed them later and much to his dismay, still didn't manage to get the pretty girls' attention being totally nude!

That was when he proceeded with peeling his own skin, remember?

There is a British magazine called 3d World which had an extensive article about the making of the video (it came with a cd with movies showing the scene from several angles); he had briefs on for the entire shoot.

Hey this isnt a fake, I saw the original footage in a post production house where they had to mosiac his cock before broadcast - just so you know this is really his cock, yes its not that big but he really wanted to make the video and this was the only way to shoot it - totally nude then mosiac on top. Im sure most people cant believe its the real thing though, but just letting you all know its really not a fake. Btw Robbie PR department then actually had to "fake" a set of briefs onto that footage in order to protect his image - I believe these were later released for publication to "prove" his naked footage was fake!

Well I heard from a friend who's connected to his record company that the whole idea of RW doing this stunt was to promote his "bad-boy" image and create a lot of good/bad press interest - lets face it, truth or fake we all know that Robbie is quite likely to do such a thing and not really care about the consequences. Whereas the record companies marketing department/PR department actually "spat the dummy" when they realised what was going to be filmed! (no doubt much to Robbies amusement). Record companies have always been the masters of spin (pun intended) and most likely part of the "myth" surrounding this "fake or not" debate was totally intentional - thats the whole purpose of self promotion anyway, and to create something as self perpetuating as this, then well it really shows that yes it WAS a great idea to shoot the video in that way. Naked or not, who will ever REALLY know? (only Robbie and the film/prodution crew!)

cool! and i can't wait for uncensored dick shots of mariah carey next!

Now that would be very scary... very mariah-scary! Eeks!

Now thats a wee wee.

im sorry but these pix are fake, its a big shame, but i know for a fact robbie is cut!

Hmmm... thats funny, I know for sure he's got a foreskin (pls dont ask how!)

Well if you know anything about lighting or just have eyes...you can tell it's a fake and "david" you're such a fake, I don't think any of us believed you...you don't deserve the honor of being called David. But it was funny to see that...or maybe creepy, that looks more like a baby's penis than an actual adult...eks!!!!!! It looks like it glows in the dark...specially since it is glowing, that's why you can see it's fake. Bye, bitches!!!!

I'm no fan of Robbie, but when he's naked, I don't care. Gimme that dick and I'll suck on it anytime. :-)

OK girls calm down, its only a few pictures (fake or otherwise) afterall! LOL! You guys just crack me up, haha!

Personally im a bit of a Robbie fan myself and thought it great to see these pics, im sure theyre fake - but i enjoyed the fantasy while it lasted at least...hehe :)

I can do a better job than this crappy and easily-recognised-its-a-fake pics.
Hire me Hire ME!

Divad (David's younger bro?), please get in touch with us, with a better photoshopped wee wee on Robbie in tow. Thanks!

no matter it's fake. i wanna his fuck!

It's real...He said himself that he wanted to become a nudist...and I Know for a fact that he did the clip nude.It said so on one of his dvd's.
Plus he's one of those cheeky lil buggers...Why wouldn't he have done it? HE'S ROBBIE WILLIAMS!

no really matter to me i want his chopper regardless!!

It annoys me that people actually think this is real, especially since he wore a flesh coloured thong while shooting the video..he actually has quite a nice dick :-)

quiero ese video

It is real...i know it iv seen him naked and its that small XD!